Am I a Cinematography-phile?

I saw Pan’s Labyrinth today, and with that, and looking at the Oscar list, I realize that I’ve inadvertently managed to see all of the movies nominated in one of the mid-weight categories.
Best Cinematography
The nominees are:
The Black Dahlia
Children of Men
The Illusionist
Pan’s Labyrinth
The Prestige
So, I guess I am qualified to judge this category, having seen all of the nominees. Still, its a tough choice and I am not sure, if I were an Oscar voter, which movie I would vote for. Black Dahlia and the Prestige, I think, are the weakest cinematographically.
COM, Illusionist and Labyrinth are all fantastic movies, and very different movies. Illusionist does the most with sticking to an unusual and deliberately archaic style. COM has gripping visuals and Pan’s Labyrinth mixes the fantastic and the real effectively. If any of those three win, I think, it would be a strong choice as opposed to Dahlia or the Prestige (which, don’t get me wrong, is a great movie, but from the viewpoint of this category, is not the strongest movie IMO)